@crazyco95

The "sorry I should've done drowning" made me explode laughing

@CSNCSNCSN

When a reference to having actually drowned as a child is the light-hearted comic relief...  😅

@adamgreenspan4988

You know Shayne has to strategically think of a “worst fear” that no one can use on him as a prank, because this is Smosh.

@sarahmcdonald4787

That went way darker than I expected😂 my dumbass was like "ok, bees and claustrophobia"

@ch222_

Missed the best quote. "I guess it's not really a fear if it's happening to all of us." 😂

@hernameispekka_Rebecca

He really showed a full Shayne spectrum in this episode! Going from "I just scream and take my shirt off" to this side of Shayne... Wow... Respect but also... BRUTAL!

@sxnny6399

The pure shock when he gave that explanation 💀

@MelxncholyMermxid

"really putting that psych degree to work"
 the psych degree being put to work

@tiffyjoan

I think Angela was all of us in that moment. The existential dread that came over all of us for sure

@rowannnnnnnnn

ALL of their jaws dropping IMMEDIATELY was incredible of the camera and editing team to capture and format into this short

@Lefty_loosey

The Brennan Lee mulligan-fication of Shayne has begun

@farmerrlad

the mickey gloves just really pulls it together

@nina.angeli_ne

But like that’s such real art 😭

@YoruMochizuki

Ive never seen angela face look so full of 
 existential dread 😅

@dopey_bear6106

OMG COURT AND ANGELA JUST LOOKING TOWARDS PRODUCTION LIKE "can...can we keep this in...??" 🤣🤣🤣 had me ROLLING omfg

@CKJohnson-pj1uw

Its amazing to watch something and know your witnessing Smosh history as it happens. This one is gonna stay with us all whether we like it or not. I was there man

@ameliarose47

When an almost dead baby is the LIGHTHEARTED part of the joke- omfg 🤣 Shayne channeled Damien for that one.

@bugsterrrrrr

I’ve never seen such beauty rolled into one outfit 🥹

@TheGhostofAbigailMills

I love how APPALLED they all look as Shayne's words really sink in.

@acgm046

The real horror was never about monsters, but about Humans vs the world system they created